How Often Should Home and Garden Brands Change Their Ad Creative?

When should you change your ad creative? It’s a question we hear all the time—and there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. In this episode of Tea Talks, Darren and Aaron break it down for home, garden, and lifestyle brands with real examples, clear advice, and a bit of fun along the way.

It Depends on Your Goals

Every brand is different. There’s no set rule. But the key thing is to align your creative with your marketing objectives.

Common objectives that affect ad frequency:

• Driving immediate conversions vs long-term brand awareness
• Launching seasonal campaigns or new products
• Building retargeting audiences

Even brands selling similar products may need completely different creative schedules based on their goals and structure.

Budget Matters More Than You Think

How much you’re spending will determine how fast you burn through your ad creative.

• Small budgets = longer shelf life for creative
• Bigger spend = more impressions = quicker fatigue

But don’t rush to change what’s working. If your ad is performing, let it run!

Let the Data Guide You

Creative decisions shouldn’t come from guesswork—they should come from your ad account.

• Watch for drop-offs in CTR or conversions
• Identify patterns based on platform or format
• Make changes only when data tells you to

Ad fatigue is real, but data will tell you exactly when it starts to creep in.

Seasonality Is a Big Deal

Your best ad might stop performing—not because it’s bad, but because the moment has passed.

Plan for:

• High-impact seasonal campaigns like Black Friday or Christmas
• Ads that can be paused and reused the following year
• Messaging that evolves with your customer’s mindset

Sometimes you’re just out of season, not out of ideas.

Business Activity Should Drive Ad Changes

Your internal calendar should sync with your ad schedule.

Ask yourself:

• Are we in a sales period?
• Are we promoting something new?
• Are we building up to a major event?

All of this should shape how often—and why—you rotate creative.

So… How Often Should You Change Creative?

Here’s the honest answer:

It depends.

But here’s a rough guide:

• Low budget + evergreen campaigns: every 6–8 weeks
• Medium budget + performance-driven: every 4–6 weeks
• High spend or short campaigns: refresh weekly or bi-weekly

The golden rule: don’t fix what isn’t broken, but don’t ignore what’s underperforming.

Your Next Steps:

• Monitor ad performance trends weekly
• Match your creative to your marketing calendar
• Repurpose strong seasonal ads year-on-year
• Always let the data guide your decisions

This is the art and science of creative testing—and it’s the key to scalable ad performance for home, garden, and lifestyle brands.

___

👋 Never miss an update. Sign up to T.E.A Break, our weekly newsletter.

👉 See our case studies to discover how we grow brands online.

👉 Subscribe to our YouTube channel.

👉 Follow our Grow with Evergreen podcast on Spotify, YouTube & Apple Podcasts.

👉 Download our new Home and Garden sector paid media report